JFK vs PP II
Time for a sequel
Some
of you might remember my post
Killer Looks where I sought to illustrate how
bad visuals, or more specifically bad Power Point,
can destroy even the greatest of speeches. My
example seemed to work quite well and I received a
fair amount of positive feedback. As the post was
also one of the most popular posts I've made, a
sequel was inevitable. The thing that irked me
about the original was that while it demonstrated
the point I was trying to make it was also rather
contrived. The Power Point Presentation was
designed to be bad and while I've
experienced similar examples in real life it did
tickle the "do-better"-itch.
The original "Boring Powerpoint" clip
The where- and whats
What if I tried to make a proper presentation to
go with the same speech? Would it still detract
from JFK's dynamic delivery? To make the experiment
more comparable to presentations in the wild I
decided not to pull out the big motion-graphics
guns. Everything was created in Apple's Keynote
which is part of the excellent
iWork
The Result
I find it hard to distance myself from my own work and the legendary status of President Kennedy's Inaugural Speech makes it even harder. I am confident that it works okay but Kennedy's charisma is so strong it will always be dificult to improve upon. I'll leave it up to you to decide whether this presentation detracts or ads to the speech...
